Why should Musk be allowed to issue billions of dollars of Tesla stock, diluting existing shareholders and putting his whole enterprise at undue risk when he could so easily acquire what he wants merely by waiting for SolarCity’s bankruptcy, which will be along shortly? So Musk’s personal brand remains unsullied?
Tesla appointed two “independent” directors to make the go/no-go decision on recommending that Tesla complete its offer to acquire SolarCity. But how independent were they? One, Nancy Pfund, had been quoted saying Elon Musk “has always been a master of the universe in my mind.” Hardly a neutral appraisal. But 80% of Tesla’s stock isn’t held by Musk, and perhaps those investors will be the ones who collectively shout, “C’mon, man. Really?”
Harvard Business Review case studies are famous for their anodyne prose and non-judgmental tone. But if HBR ever publishes the facts and analysis of this proposed deal, in my opinion, it will be hard not to point out the sheer ridiculousness of the whole thing.
